The Sacred City of Mecca: Have We Got It Wrong? | TRACKS

Share
HTML-code

Comments • 17 292

  • Sikh Bhavikh
    Sikh Bhavikh  57 minutes back

    Jerusalem is actually in Southern Africa as how the Bible says. Research that the modern day Jerusalem is counterfeit and how many people believe it’s the true holy city of YahVah. Namibia is where the true Jerusalem is as it lays desolate as it says it would be in there days.

    Freemasons and Jesuits have ruined everything historical nowadays so do your research before accepting anything. School system is a fraud lying to the masses.

    • Zia Minhas
      Zia Minhas  1 hours back

      narrow minded idiot

      • Zia Minhas
        Zia Minhas  2 hours back

        good propaganda. youre fooling noone but yourselves

        • Sharib Ansari
          Sharib Ansari  2 hours back

          This guy's the initial thing wrong...Mecca is not the birthplace of Islam.....it's the place of completion of Islam and the birth place of the final messenger of GOD...his whole research is based on a wrong idea.....

          • Abdur-Razzaq Muawia
            Abdur-Razzaq Muawia  2 hours back

            I am scared in the the book it said it never changed so.....
            I'm only 10
            No no no no no no no
            Petra why did it have to be you
            Oh no but Allah said that
            Maybe he changed something

            • Umar Marsh
              Umar Marsh  3 hours back

              It all starts here:
              Ismail Covenant only Proof of Muhammad's (Peace and blessings be upon him) Prophethood from the Bible, the Old and New Testaments: Proof that the covenant had to remain with Ismail: To refute the baseless claim that Ismail was not an heir to Abraham because Hajjar was merely a concubine (Peace be upon them all), the Hebrew text as well as many Biblical translations say, "Take Hajjar as thine wife"! The purpose in the first place for Abraham (Peace be upon him) Sarah's suggestion that he marry Hajjar (Peace be upon them) was to continued his seed by bearing him legitimate heirs to fulfil Allah's Covenant as Sarah (Peace be upon her) realized she was barren and well beyond Child-bearing age, but Allah intervened and blessed her with Abraham's second son Issac (Peace be upon them all). LOGIC— WHICH CHRISTIANS SEEM TO LACK—WHY BEAR A CHILD WITH A CONCUBINE WHO CANNOT INHERIT. ABRAHAM WOULD BE BACK TO SQUARE ONE—HOW RIDICULOUS! The verse below disproves any notion of an acrimonious relationship between the two 'blessed brother's Ismail and Issac "Iss'haq in Arabic" (peace be upon them both), as is propounded by many rabbinical and Evangelical schools. Look at the blatant cover up where it erroneously calls Isaac (Peace be upon him) The only son, and then adds the line 'whom you love'. That's a clearly added nonessential relative clause which does not negate the fact that Isaac was never the only son. The circumcision and the covenant were first done with the first son. Now look at this: King James Bible Genesis 22:12 And he said, Lay not thine hand upon the lad, neither do thou any thing unto him: for now I know that thou fearest God, seeing thou hast not withheld thy son, thine ONLY son from me. Genesis 25:9 And his sons Isaac and ISHMAEL buried him in the cave of Machpelah, in the field of Ephron the son of Zohar the Hittite, which is before Mamre; [10] The field which Abraham purchased of the sons of Heth: there was Abraham buried, and Sarah his wife.§ How did Ismail (Peace be upon him) magically become a son again if Priests and Rabbis claim he's not a real son? I guess they forgot to change this part. This is clear tampering of the book by scribes in the past. I had to go through quite a few conundrums to get straight to the verse about the first born of the second hated wife. The King James and all of the other Occidental Bible versions totally confuse the wording in a clear attempt to mislead. Finally I got this. The Torah says: ["When a man has TWO WIVES... and the loved one and the hated one both bear him children, and the first-born son belongs to the wife that is hated. Then it shall be, on the day that he bequeaths to his sons that what he will have, he will not be allowed to declare the son of the loved wife his first-born, in face of the first-born son of the hated one. But the first-born , the son of the wife who is disliked shall he acknowledge, to give him double of all that he has in his possession; because he is the first of his power, and to him belongs the birthright. " (Devorim 21:15-17)] So then, how on earth would it be  permitted to switch the birthright from one son to the other? "If a man has two wives". Why is the Bible trying to hide this. Even some of the commentary by rabbis try to blur the two wife reference and say that one wife had been divorced. Furthermore, the notion that jealousy and acrimony existed between the wives and children of Sarah and Hajar (Peace be upon them all) is clearly another attempt to discredit the line of Ismail (Peace be upon him) via a story concocted in the minds of some jealous rabbis who seeth with rage at having lost their 'chosen' status and having been replaced by Muslims who are chosen by God—as individuals—to become Muslim from all walks of life. No more special status for Jews. By Christian ministers, Ismail has been called everything from illegitimate, to a wild donkey of a man, to the pariah of mankind, yet the Bible states he was blessed and would become a great nation and was mentioned at the burial of their father Abraham??? (Peace be upon them all). The attempt to discredit Ismail was so bad that it took comical proportions where he would have had to have been a full-blown teenager when his mother was running around the hillocks of Safa and Marwa in Makkah, looking for water so that she could "breastfeed" her 'teenage' child. I even saw a ridiculous TV Bible story to this effect which couldn't reconcile the ridiculous chronological discrepancy, and here was this woman running around about to collapse all bandy-legged with this big ole boy head bouncing.
              But yet when Hajjar, was running around the hillocks in Makkah, she was holding a suckling infant!
              The old name for Makkah is "Bakah". Makkah us the Qureishi dialect pronunciation.

              The Bible says that Sarah sent a baby "Ismail" and his mother away because he "the baby" was making fun of Issac (Peace be upon them all)

              Genesis 21: 8-21
              8 The child grew and was weaned, and on the day Isaac was weaned Abraham held a great feast. 9 But Sarah saw that the son whom Hagar the Egyptian had borne to Abraham was mocking, 10 and she said to Abraham, “Get rid of that slave woman and her son, for that woman’s son will never share in the inheritance with my son Isaac.”

              Look at the contradictions and weak and ridiculous depiction of Prophet Abraham's character and the apparent malice of Sarah. This is an outright lie by nefarious scribes who tampered with the Old Testament. Just like the ridiculous notion that birth rights can be actually sold! Look at this Bible interpretation skulduggery:
              "The Book of Genesis speaks of the relationship between fraternal twins Jacob and Esau, sons of Isaac and Rebekah, focusing on Esau's loss of his birthright to Jacob and the conflict that ensued between their descendant nations because of Jacob's deception of their aged and blind father, Isaac, in order to receive Esau's birthright/blessing from Isaac.
              This conflict was paralleled by the affection the parents had for their favored child: "Isaac, who had a taste for wild game, loved Esau, but Rebekah loved Jacob." (Genesis 25:28).
              Even since conception, their conflict was foreshadowed: "And the children struggled together within her; and she said, If it be so, why am I thus? And she went to enquire of the LORD. And the LORD said unto her, Two nations are in thy womb, and two manner of people shall be separated from thy bowels; and the one people shall be stronger than the other people; and the elder shall serve the younger." (Genesis 25:22–23)
              Genesis 25:26 states that Esau was born before Jacob, who came out holding on to his older brothers heel as if he was trying to pull Esau back into the womb so that he could be firstborn.[1] The name Jacob means he grasps the heel which is a Hebrew idiom for deceptive behavior."

              The Bible clearly points to the Pilgrimage to Makkah in Psalms 84, 5-6
              5) Blessed is the man whose strength is in You, Whose heart is set on pilgrimage.
              6) As they pass through the Valley of Baca, They make it a spring; The rain also covers it with pools.
              Every Hajj and Ramadan for Umrah "the smaller Hajj" when about 3 million pilgrims converge on Makkah from every end of the world, It usually pours rain before and after the the holy guests come when the rest of the country is borne dry, including Jeddah "port city" which is closer to the sea than Makkah by 100 kilometers! This is an easily verifiable miracle because Makkah is on live video 24 hours, 7 days a week.
              Here's one app:
              http://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.qsdapps.makkahlive

              • makedonistoi
                makedonistoi  6 minutes back

                so u are admit islam is grafted in from judaism as is christianity via the old testament,ur prophet abraham was directed by GOD to covenant with isaak,why so much hate to ur jewish brethren ...just to revise history to make ishmael ruler?

            • Purple Rocket
              Purple Rocket  4 hours back

              I'm a muslim. Form now on, I will be facing Petra for prayer. It is the birth place of Muhammad (PBUH).

              • ScatteredTruth
                ScatteredTruth  4 hours back

                Don't try to mislead Muslims and mind your own business.
                No doubt Allah s.w.t knows better how to protect final religion Islam and final scripture Quran on this earth. Kibla our Kaaba and Macca is our holy place with all its evidences.
                May Allah s.w.t protect us from dajjali fitnah.

                • MohdIbrahim Hassim
                  MohdIbrahim Hassim  4 hours back

                  Worship black stone? did he ever ask Muslim people true about that?... whos is Muslim answer their worship black stone?

                  • Mohammed Ali Al Balushi

                    Wrong.....My father Abraham Built the Kabah. It is correct.

                    • Feroz Khan
                      Feroz Khan  4 hours back

                      His 30 years of living in middle east cant change the 1500 years old history.

                      If you want to know truth and history of islam read Quran with translation you will find all the answers and what islam says as well.

                      • Rob Vollat
                        Rob Vollat  3 hours back

                        .... So.. evidence somehow doesn't count because second hand accounts written down in 800 a.d.? Did you not even watch this video? The Koran and this theory can both be right. In fact, they cannot both be right. So you better hope the Koran chroniclers knew what they were talking about; because he does.

                    • Meaghan Galvin
                      Meaghan Galvin  6 hours back

                      Had it occurred to anyone else...
                      That our only food has been ...
                      A steady diet of nothing but
                      Lies..followed by more lies.
                      And nothing to was it down w/polluted or dead water!!
                      🌎🌏🔍👀🤔😎

                      • Umar Marsh
                        Umar Marsh  7 hours back

                        Ismail Covenant; Zamzam!!

                        I had to go through quite a few conundrums to get straight to the verse about the first born of the second hated wife. I even ran into translations with ridiculous spelling errors. The King James and all of the other Occidental Bible versions totally confuse the wording in a clear attempt to mislead. Finally I got this. The Torah says: ["When a man has two wives... and the loved one and the hated one both bear him children, and the first-born son belongs to the wife that is hated. Then it shall be, on the day that he bequeaths to his sons that what he will have, he will not be allowed to declare the son of the loved wife his first-born, in face of the first-born son of the hated one. But the first-born , the son of the wife who is disliked shall he acknowledge, to give him double of all that he has in his possession; because he is the first of his power, and to him belongs the birthright. " (Devorim 21:15-17)] So then, how on earth would it be  permitted to switch the birthright from one son to the other? "If a man has two wives". Why is the Bible trying to hide this. Even some of the commentary by rabbis try to blur the two wife reference and say that one wife had been divorced. Furthermore, the notion that jealousy and acrimony existed between the wives and children of Sarah and Hajar (Peace be upon) them all is clearly another attempt to discredit the line of Ismail (Peace be upon him) via a story concocted in the minds of jealous rabbis who seeth with rage at having lost their 'chosen' status and having been replaced by Muslims who are chosen as individuals to become Muslim from all walks of life. No more special status for Jews. By Christian ministers, Ismail has been called everything from illegitimate, to a wild donkey of a man, to the pariah of mankind, yet the Bible states he was blessed and sold become a great nation and was mentioned at the burial of their father Abraham??? (Peace be upon them all). The attempt to discredit Ismail was so bad that it took comical proportions where he would gave had to have been a full-blown teenager when his mother was running around the hillocks of Safa and Marwa in Makkah, looking for water so that she could "breastfeed" her 'teenage' child. I even saw a ridiculous TV Bible story to this effect which couldn't reconcile the ridiculous chronological discrepancy, and here was this woman running around bandi-legged with this big ole boy head bouncing, and  respect to his virtues and awesome deeds, no Prophet like Moses, whom the Lord knows face to face, no longer appeared among Israel. http://youtu.be/cFL5vTItXHI

                        The attempt to discredit Ismail was so bad that it took comical proportions where he would gave had to have been a full-blown teenager when his mother was running around the hillocks of Safa and Marwa in Makkah, looking for water so that she could "breastfeed" her 'teenage' child. I even saw a ridiculous TV Bible story to this effect which couldn't reconcile the ridiculous chronological discrepancy, and here was this woman running around bandi-legged with this big ole boy head bouncing, and  respect to his virtues and awesome deeds, no Prophet like Moses, whom the Lord knows face to face, no longer appeared among Israel. http://youtu.be/cFL5vTItXHI

                        Proofs of Muhammad's Prophethood (Peace and blessings be upon him): An UNDENIABLE fact is that Muhammad (Peace and blessings be upon him) is the ONLY Prophet for whom there is physical evidence, even DNA, that he ever existed. Others would be arguably folklore were it not for the evidence in the Qur'an whose medium was a 'verifiable' Prophet. Needless to say, we Muslims believe in all of the Biblical Prophets and do not curse or disparage any of them (Peace be upon the all). Forward is a partial description of the irreproachable, verifiable Prophet of Allah, Muhammad: http://youtu.be/QzAbwNGvbZE

                        CONTINUED—1

                        • Umar Marsh
                          Umar Marsh  7 hours back

                          This skulduggery targets laypeople with no background about Islam and / or too lazy to seek for themselves. These "hypothesis" are so ridiculous they don't warrant answering. This Jew, Gibson, says he researched and "translated" historical evidence whilst his slaughtering of the Arabic language belies his ability to translate a sentence much less ancient manuscripts. Arabs of Making possess genealogy trees going all the way back to Abraham and Ismail (Peace be upon them all). I suggest these charlatans stick to digging in Jerusalem like moles for nonexistent pieces of pottery to prove a Jew were there.
                          ZAMZAM

                          Dr. Masaru Emoto
                          http://youtu.be/s3DxELxeSLk

                          http://youtu.be/3TLzFeaVCX4

                          Source for ZamZam Well

                          #1 by afridi220 on 05 Oct, 2007

                          TECHNICAL INFORMATION
                          The Zamzam Well is 30 meters deep, and the water level is 3.23 meters below the surface. A pumping test at 8000 liters/second for more than a 24 hour period showed a drop in water level from 3.23 meters below surface to 12.72 meters and then to 13.39 meters, after which the water level stopped receding. When pumping stopped, the water level recovered to 3.9 meters below surface only 11 minutes later. This data shows that the aquifer feeding the well seems to recharge from rock fractures in neighboring mountains around Mecca

                          After being in use for many centuries, it disappeared after the Bani Jurham, a tribe of Makkah in whom Ismael was married, filled it up with soil before leaving Makkah. It remained obliterated and untraced for quite a few centuries till its location was disclosed in a dream to Abdul Mutallib, the grandfather of Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon him) in the first half of the 6th century AD, that is about 540 AD. Hazrat Abdul Mutallib, in spite of opposition from the local leaders and chieftains of Makkah, excavated the ground with the help of his only son, Haris, till he found the well (in all, he was blessed with ten sons, but nine were borne after the rediscovery of Zam Zam).

                          The well’s dimension of 18ft x 12ft x 5ft of water depth was measured in 1971 by Tariq Hussain, a Pakistani chemical engineer who was then working with the Saline Water Desalination Corporation at the Jeddah plant. He was assigned to take a water sample from the well of Zam Zam for chemical and biological examination, and to disprove the claim of an Egyptian doctor that the water of Zam Zam is contaminated with sewage leakages from Makkah’s sewage system. The dimensions measured by Tariq Hussain in 1971 are the same to which the well was excavated by Hazrat Abdul Mutallib, and has remained unaltered for 1,400 years.

                          The city of Makkah is located in a valley with hard, granite mountains on all sides, and the Haram Sharif (Masjid-ul-Haram) located at its lowest point. There is about 50 to 100ft deep sandy silt formation underlain by igneous rocks. The well of Zam Zam is located in this sand/silt formation and its water level is about 40 to 50ft below the natural ground level.

                          The source of the well of Zam Zam has been traced to an aquifer extending out to the hills of Taif. This was accidentally discovered in June 1982, while a tunnel on the Safa side of Haram Sharif was being excavated. While excavating the tunnel roof, water profusely started flowing, so much so that the contractor was confronted with a difficult situation. At the same time, the flow into the Zam Zam well turned slack and for the first time in 1,400 years, the well almost ran dry. His Majesty, King Fahad of Saudi Arabia, immediately appointed a committee to look into the matter that included Dr Adnan Niazi, professor of Geo-Physics at King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals Dhahran, Saudi Arabia.

                          The water tests showed that the tunnel water and the water in the well of Zam Zam were the same and therefore it was confirmed that the tunnelling operation had ruptured the aquifer bringing water to the well. Immediate repairs were undertaken and as the rupture was closed, the Zam Zam flow was restored. A visit to the tunnel saw almost a flood coming out of the ruptured roof of the tunnel in the month of Ramadan in June 1982. The well of Zam Zam used to have a manual system of drawing water, until the early 1950s. In those days, the peak discharge drawn during the Hajj season would just suffice the number of Hajjis not exceeding a hundred thousand.

                          Today, Hajjis exceed 2.2 million and in addition, the Zam Zam water is being pumped to Masjid-i-Nabbi in Madinah through a 450km-long pipeline from Makkah. The installed pump capacity today is 3 cft/sec (1,350 gallon/minute).

                          The well of Zam Zam has been in operation since the last 1,450 years at a stretch. Until an electric motor and pump was installed in the late 1940s or the early 50s, the discharge never exceeded 0.05 cft/sec (about 22.5 gallons per minute). The discharge from the well since then is on a constant rise with an increase in the number of Hajis. It has now reached 3cft/sec (1,346 gallons per minute) and runs constantly for hours per day, and sometimes without stopping for days.

                          Today, Zam Zam water is supplied to 2.2 million Hajjis during the Haj season and to Madinah. Any open well in the world, after a few years, suffers from the growth of algae, making water unpalatable and causing taste and odour problems. Here, Zam Zam has been operational for fourteen centuries without any biological or algae growth, and remains in use without any kind of treatment (recently chlorination is being done by Saudi authorities).

                          --------------------------------------------

                          There is no any kind of holy water like Zam Zam of Islam in qualities in whole Page on world.so it is 100% natural, neutral and irrefutable proof on truth of Islam. If Allah is not God, Muhammad (peace be upon him) is not last and true prophet , Holy Quran is not true book then why the other gods, other religions and other prophets or holy persons do not have holy water like the holy water Zam Zan near holy Kaaba in holy city Mecca? The reality is that except religion Islam all religions are cancelled, incomplete or false.

                          You can call it a miracle!!

                          Zam-Zam well has a diameter of 1.46-2.66 m, and has a depth of about 30 m still it is able to quench the thirst of billions of pilgrims every year since centuries.
                          Even when all other wells around Mecca dry up. The zam-zam well will be still there.
                          It was miraculously created by baby Prophet Ismail (a.s.).
                          There are more notable points about zam-zam water-

                          1) It has been scientifically proven that its contents are different from other water wells near Mecca.

                          2) It contains more calcium and magnesium than the other wells.

                          3) Even though it never been treated with chemicals but it contains fluorides which can prevent bacteria growth and beneficial for health without any water treatment.

                          4) It has always maintained same salt composition and taste.

                          5) Even if you keep it still in a bottle or something for a long time, it will remain clear and appropriate for consumption.

                          6) It will never run out and always fulfill the requirement .

                          7) It has never overflowed.

                          8) It can quench your thirst and fill your stomach at the same time.

                          9) And the greatest miracle of all is that its non stop flow in the middle of a dessert.


                          Cesar A. K. Grossmann, studied Electrical Engineering at Federal University of Santa Maria (1993)

                          • Anne Brit Raaen
                            Anne Brit Raaen  8 hours back

                            Pray to Jesus- he don't care about the location- he only wants your heart.

                            • REAL SH
                              REAL SH  1 hours back

                              Jesus never said pray to him he said pary to my lord and your lord " the father " , Read your bible

                            • Mimi Momo
                              Mimi Momo  7 hours back

                              you should be muslim

                          • Khalid Sharif
                            Khalid Sharif  8 hours back

                            Where the zam zam water came from

                          • John Linden
                            John Linden  8 hours back

                            I SUPPOSE IT DOES NO HARM TO PRAY TOWARD THE CITY OF MECCA OR THE WALK AROUND THIS SACRED ? STONE WITH THOUSANDS OF OTHER BELIEVERS ! AS WELL WITH JEWS BOWING AT THE WAILING WALL IN JERUSALEM ! AND CHRISTIAN, HINDUS AND OTHER RELIGIOUS BELIEVERS INDULGE IN THEIR VARIOUS RITUALS AND BEHAVIOURS THAT HOLD NO REAL POWER OTHER THAN THAT HELD IN THE MINDS OF THE ADHERANTS ! WE HUMANS OUGHT TO PUT OUR ENERGIES AND RESOURCES INTO MORE FRUITFUL IDEAS AND ACTIVITIES THAT WOULD BE BENEFICIAL TO HUMANKIND AND ALL LIFE ON OUR WORLD !

                            • atime ahcene
                              atime ahcene  8 hours back

                              Nice try,this is very silly and stupid documentary,since the born of islam millions of muslims visite mecca for Hajj,for Omra and for study islam so it is impossible to make a huge mistake as you are trying to say,

                              • s s
                                s s  8 hours back

                                Our Lord, I have established some of my offspring in an uncultivated valley, close to Your Sacred House, Lord, so that they may keep up the prayer. Make people’s hearts turn to them, and provide them with produce, so that they may be thankful.
                                SURAT IBRAHIM 37 DESTROYED ALL YOUR NONSENSE A 1 HAUR 24 MINUTE AND 45 SECONDS VIDEO.
                                ALLAH SAID IN THIS AYA"IBRAHIM SAID THAT HE(IBRAHIM) I settled some of my offspring in an anncultivated valley near your Sacred house.
                                WHY ALL YOUR PROOFS ARE THE SUNNAH? WHY YOU CHOOSE SOMETHING YOU WANT TO CONVINCE YOURSELF? THE BIG QUESTION IS WHY YOU DELIBERATELY IGNORED THE HOLY QURAN??? BECCA IS MECCA.
                                PEACE!

                                • Spot The Cat
                                  Spot The Cat  8 hours back

                                  _"SURAT IBRAHIM 37 DESTROYED ALL YOUR NONSENSE A 1 HAUR 24 MINUTE AND 45 SECONDS VIDEO. "_


                                  Not really , what came shortly after Hagar and Ismail were abandoned ? The 'miracle' of Zam Zam water and a whole bunch of people (presumably with animals of some sort ) , two of the things needed to *start cultivation* !

                              • TrRazZ 3X
                                TrRazZ 3X  9 hours back

                                There’s just so many things wrong with this and the annoying thing is there not even Muslims so they wouldn’t know everything and be sure in what there saying because the main thing is that Arabia back then was known as a baron desert with less water at that time to and not Mecca being an amazing wonderland everyone knows about but the main thing is if no one started the city of Mecca and was made at the start of its history then I’m pretty sure it wouldn’t be a city today would it

                                • Vasim Shaikh
                                  Vasim Shaikh  9 hours back

                                  This is all illogical, the well of Zamzam is still there, which cannot be changed

                                • Ibootje Cap
                                  Ibootje Cap  11 hours back

                                  The place used to called BECCA !

                                • Arfan Khan
                                  Arfan Khan  11 hours back

                                  It is a good way to brainwash muslims.

                                  • Harry Browneigh
                                    Harry Browneigh  8 hours back

                                    Hard to "wash" something that one doesn't have.

                                • SID
                                  SID  12 hours back

                                  imagine they found other culture construction and gods buried underneath the sands of time....A muslims would bury it again and construct something over it... or maybe actually happened already somewhere...what do u think

                                  • Hh Bb
                                    Hh Bb  12 hours back

                                    What you are talking about ??!!
                                    You study history and you dont hear about Quraish
                                    And where prophet Ebraham ???!!! The main thing of prophet Muhamad teaching is the life of Ebraham
                                    And we dont worship to black stone we worship to one god Allah ...and praying to one kibla is Kaaba in Mecca
                                    And you forget zamzam water ...it discovered befor islam and who it will change its place

                                    • Amin Zribi
                                      Amin Zribi  12 hours back

                                      Dan sadly you are wrong,
                                      1) Makkah or Bekkah is between 2 mountains in a valley, which had no people living there to begin with that's why it was unknown, according to Allah is where he built his first house and the angels built it, then later it was destroyed.
                                      2) The city was built by prophet ibrahim and his son, and it was where ibrahim left his wife and son to be tested by god his wife and son where gonna starve to death because the place had no water or food so it was literally an empty valley no trees or nothing important about it.
                                      3) Petra was built before the prophet ibrahim and during prophet ibrahim time it had people and water and resources so it cant be the location.
                                      4) The city was unknown to the outside world because it was new and didn't have many people only travellers also and new comers also it was in the middle of no where also empires didn't dare to enter desert areas because its deserts its considered nothing of importance also its very risky place to take an army too.
                                      5) Also it is not true that early mosques head towards Petra they actually neither towards makkah or Petra, and the reason it was hard to pinpoint makkah direction because the earth is roundly and there was no compasses or GPS at that time therefore people used to make estimations at that time, and a 1 degree can make a difference.

                                      I just can't emphasises how wrong you are that I can give you at least 20 reasons but I am giving only 5.

                                      • santana bitch
                                        santana bitch  12 hours back

                                        Muhammed have to bee wrong that he says he is a last profit....because I am a messenger of God...2...

                                        • santana bitch
                                          santana bitch  12 hours back

                                          I also believed that Muhammed said he was a messenger...so why didn't ALLAH say that with his own mouth...in his own book.......or is it that he never speaks

                                          • Shadowmistress Wimpy
                                            Shadowmistress Wimpy  12 hours back

                                            If a God reveals himself to the world,the world is dead sir,imagine infinite source of energy.,human body has limitation,Had he not been prophet,there wont these much population in billions following him,there must be something....

                                        • santana bitch
                                          santana bitch  12 hours back

                                          If Allah is the reel god.why does the middle East are full of hatred and war....that's all they contributed to the world...Muhammed commanded to fight with the sword, Jesus said those who use the sword will die by the sword.

                                          • Hh Bb
                                            Hh Bb  12 hours back

                                            With all due respect, you don't know who's causing the wars in the Middle East. It is not the muslims, but the great powers
                                            and the prophet muhammad did not spread the Muslim religion with the sword, but the sword was the defence, and battles have been common among all peoples for a thousand and four hundred years. Islam has established strict rules to respect the truce in wars and to respect and not to harm non-combatants, women, children and places of worship of other religions. Don't speak without study and fanaticism... Read from neutral sources and speak.

                                        • Adam Chaudhary
                                          Adam Chaudhary  13 hours back

                                          This is the most ridiculous fakeumentry ive seen. Twisted facts, lack of historical evedience. What a pity state these so called academic western scholars come to?

                                          • taariqq
                                            taariqq  13 hours back

                                            Where did they get the idea that the birthplace of Mu'hammad (peace be upon him) was an agricultural place!

                                            • Mimi Momo
                                              Mimi Momo  7 hours back

                                              @J we say it to jesus too

                                            • taariqq
                                              taariqq  9 hours back

                                              @J It is the case with all the Prophets when we pray for them. May peace and Mercy of Allaah be upon them all. He is the ultimate authority.

                                            • taariqq
                                              taariqq  10 hours back

                                              @J Not sure I understand you. Was there a question in there?

                                            • J
                                              J  11 hours back

                                              Why do you always have to say peace be upon him? Not sure of his salvation huh.

                                          • Fr Louie Goad
                                            Fr Louie Goad  13 hours back

                                            Islam is all "BS"! God is! Christ is! NO-Others.

                                            • Alexander the great
                                              Alexander the great  13 hours back

                                              How much are they paying you guys to misguide us....report this video guys. Liars. Shame on you liars who made this useless video and shame on jewtube for allowing this nonsense.

                                              • Spot The Cat
                                                Spot The Cat  8 hours back

                                                Being paid ? It's the Jews ? Report this video ? The standard response of the inveterate whiners of the religion of permanent offence .

                                            • rachel kennedy
                                              rachel kennedy  14 hours back

                                              That is because the same parasites that created wahhabism also created Islam. islam is only about 200 years old. All of His Story we have been 'taught' is lies

                                            • Eye on a Sphere
                                              Eye on a Sphere  15 hours back

                                              Is that Allahs kabba or the Kaballah?

                                              • Excrementi Cranium
                                                Excrementi Cranium  15 hours back

                                                The world would be a better place without Islam. Islam has brought disaster to every country and culture it has been in contact with. Islam is a total deception.

                                                • TERRASOLUSI CONSULTANT
                                                  TERRASOLUSI CONSULTANT  15 hours back

                                                  useless movie. face to mecca meaning face where direction to. is not in certain degrees. This movie only to destruct Islamic believer?? Wallahu A'lam Bissawab,

                                                  • SPillay
                                                    SPillay  15 hours back

                                                    As usual Muslims wants to stay in a cave n if possible throw away the key.... ignorant n not emphasis in education, no wonder they r afraid of israel🤣

                                                    • Muhd.Shafqat Murad
                                                      Muhd.Shafqat Murad  16 hours back

                                                      Appreciable endeavours by all team,researchers,professors,archaeologists & others who contributed in one way or the others in creating such informative but controversial programme.
                                                      All the points raised with evidence hold grounds but inconsistency mars their health. Traditionalists,Reformists & Middle ones fighting for supremacy is not a secret but rest assured in any case they would have never crossed limits set by Allah & His Messenger PBUH.There were top class Progency of the Prophet PBUH, theologists & leaders of emerging school ofthoughts & jurisprudence.Your reference of Al Tabari is okay but what about others.Why didn't they raise such sensitive issue & kept mum? What forced their silence?
                                                      Traditionalists,Reformists & Middle-one were preceded by the Pious Caliph,again the questionis why?
                                                      The entire episode revolves around Mecca & Petra neglecting many other places of supreme importance in Islam. The Safa & Marwa mountain, Zam Zam fountain & The Prophet's mosque. Islamic & regional history is always incomplete without places mentioned before as sequence of events intertwined them.

                                                      • Osmanian
                                                        Osmanian  16 hours back

                                                        good attempt to full muslims

                                                        • amuthi1
                                                          amuthi1  17 hours back

                                                          Signs of Allah in nature according to the Quran point away from desert regions. See: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ChIEV5Ny734&t=29s

                                                          • worfoz
                                                            worfoz  15 hours back

                                                            did alla made that video?

                                                        • noble136
                                                          noble136  17 hours back

                                                          To me this documentary is trying to use historical errors which was made by Muslims them self to disrespect Islam. I don’t think this will change true Muslims believe.

                                                          • worfoz
                                                            worfoz  15 hours back

                                                            to you every truth is an attack because you are a paranoid muhamedan
                                                            but we do science not to please or annoy you, and I am sorry that you always talk about us like that:
                                                            can you try and respect the creators of your car and internet, we do science, we love truth and we do not want to harm you
                                                            please do not be so hostile, suspicious and accusing
                                                            If you disrespect us, just stoop using our internet and you don't hate to be afraid and accusing, OK?
                                                            We do not care about your beliefs but your paranoid and hostile attitude is most offensive and wrong, stop that
                                                            and see a doctor

                                                        • Tanveer BIN TAHIR
                                                          Tanveer BIN TAHIR  17 hours back

                                                          How crazy this video and give us full wrong information..... Last 1400 years hajj and prayers on going non stop in macca but this video ..... Omg.. how can devils whisper in ear of people... I'm just shocked

                                                          • worfoz
                                                            worfoz  14 hours back

                                                            and why do you need to lie about the bible?
                                                            or did you mean you corrupted your book too many times?


                                                            you muhamedans are such stupid terrorists, like muhamed: you can't read and you talk talk talk


                                                            until we kill you, like muhamed was killed by a woman
                                                            lol
                                                            and your demon alla still thinks earth is flat

                                                          • worfoz
                                                            worfoz  15 hours back

                                                            @Tanveer BIN TAHIR I dare to make fun of your sect full of stolen lies, my friend, yes why not?
                                                            You terrorists are so funny, fearing muhameds associate and hating real religions you simply can not understand.


                                                            we don't make bibles, we make computers, we are the creators and we upgrade them, like YOU should update your outdated book quran


                                                            did you know that earth is not flat anymore? That makes ten errors in your quran
                                                            did you know we created Google Earth? That's number 11: alla is not the creator of everything


                                                            now what?
                                                            was your alla drunk when she made your book?

                                                          • Tanveer BIN TAHIR
                                                            Tanveer BIN TAHIR  15 hours back

                                                            @worfoz nevermind seems like im selling mirror in the city of blind.you guys amend and make new edition of your own bible ...........now you dare talk with us about religion?

                                                          • worfoz
                                                            worfoz  15 hours back

                                                            lol, that's because you muhamedans can not handle the truth
                                                            using our internet must be like being in hell for you poor misguided slaves of demon alla


                                                            so why are you here?

                                                        • M J
                                                          M J  17 hours back

                                                          The facts from this documentary is enough for any muslim to leave Islam unless he/she brainwashed so hard

                                                          • speed of link
                                                            speed of link  17 hours back

                                                            Why, do you also think Darwin's theory of evolution should make Christians leave their faith?

                                                        • وليد الردادي
                                                          وليد الردادي  17 hours back

                                                          The quran said before 1440 years
                                                          The people will visit makkah every year. Acording to your lie no one know makkah why now every day in the year there is visitor.
                                                          The quran is the word of the god you will not find one wrong information in the quran

                                                          • Spot The Cat
                                                            Spot The Cat  15 hours back

                                                            Where in the Quran does it say that people will visit 'Makkah' every year, chapter and verse please?

                                                          • وليد الردادي
                                                            وليد الردادي  17 hours back

                                                            The word*

                                                        • Hahn Solo
                                                          Hahn Solo  17 hours back

                                                          Muhammad was nothing but a war monger. All religions are lies

                                                          • harris khan
                                                            harris khan  17 hours back

                                                            The presence of Zamzam well in Mecca provides a clear proof that Mecca is the Sacred City of Islam. Read this extract from Wikipedia:
                                                            Islamic tradition states that the Zamzam Well was revealed to Hajara, the second wife of Ibrahim[2] and mother of ʾIsmaʿil.[3] By the instruction of God, Ibrahim left his wife and son at a spot in the desert and walked away. She was desperately seeking water for her infant son, but she could not find any, as Mecca is located in a hot dry valley with few sources of water. Hajar ran seven times back and forth in the scorching heat between the two hills of Safa and Marwah, looking for water. Getting thirstier by the second, the infant Ishmael scraped the land with his feet, where suddenly water sprang out. There are other versions of the story involving God sending his angel, Gabriel (Jibra'il), who kicked the ground with his heel (or wing), and the water rose.[4] A similar story about a well is also mentioned in the Bible.[5]

                                                            • Spot The Cat
                                                              Spot The Cat  15 hours back

                                                              _"The presence of Zamzam well in Mecca provides a clear proof that Mecca is the Sacred City of Islam."_


                                                              It proves that there is a well in Mecca (KSA) that been named 'Zam Zam', nothing more and as with just about every other Muslim here you seem to think repeating your Islamic beliefs amounts to any argument, it does not.

                                                          • harris khan
                                                            harris khan  17 hours back

                                                            challenge Mr. Gibson himself and asking him with all the respect of his study for nothing; why he did not disclosed information of Muhammad's his own Mosque's qibla which he prayed until he died. Moqque of Prophet which gets more visitors thru out every year (Umrah) more than Ka'aba itself. Since Muhammad's Hijra to city of Madina until he died which direction he faced for pray. How come this so called theory excluded this information from people.
                                                            Historical works are established with chronological orders and this so called work excludes the Mosque's Qibla (City of Madina) where Muhammad lived, established his State and ruled his followers and where he died.
                                                            Mr. Gibson mentioned many masjeed's names and their Qibla position with today's sattelite thecnology and internet etc. but did not dare to challenge most important Masjeed of Islam (which still is) Muhammad's own Masjeed ( Masjeed-un Nabawe) why, because it would destroy his own theory!

                                                            • worfoz
                                                              worfoz  15 hours back

                                                              You need to learn to use logic, my friend, not fear and anger.

                                                            • Spot The Cat
                                                              Spot The Cat  15 hours back

                                                              Quba mosque and the 'prophets' mosque have both been rebuilt and it is not possible to determine their original qibla therefore they can neither prove nor disprove his theory. If you go to his website thesacredcity.ca you can check all of the mosques using his 'qibla tool'